Page 1 of 2

Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Sat Jan 29, 2022 11:51 am
by smoke_15
My connection bandwidth is far more than what the router (archer c7 running 1.12) can serve but was curious if it's still worth turning on default QoS. My max upload is 10Mbps so I've got it on in the upload direction. For the downloads, i connected my laptop directly to the modem (wired) and got 380Mbps. I then connected directly to the archer ports and got 160Mbps. Wifi 5g (40Mhz channel) can't seem to get past 120Mbps due to neighbors using 80Mhz channels.
Ive got QoS turned off on the Download side since I'll never max out the pipe but am curious if the ACC and default QoS will improve performance.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Sat Jan 29, 2022 6:49 pm
by Lantis
They will lower max throughput to maintain excellent latency conditions.
You’ll probably top out at 100mbps with it on if I had to guess.

It’s really a situation of try it and see. Everyone’s connection is going to behave slightly differently.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Sun Jan 30, 2022 11:31 pm
by smoke_15
I figured the same thing, a tradeoff between bandwidth and latency. Ran some tests with it on and it caps off at 55Mbps. For me though I'll definitely keep it on since I've got lots of users who stream while I work remote so need it to be responsive for things like video calls.
I'll get one of the supported marvell armada chipset routers if I need the bandwidth later on. From reading the threads, those routers seem to be reasonably priced for the performance.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Mon Jan 31, 2022 2:41 am
by Lantis
Just be aware of wifi compatibility issues with those devices. They make excellent routers, but pretty woeful APs.
You’d actually do well to get one cheaply and then use your existing archer as the access point. Let them both do what they do best as individuals.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Mon Jan 31, 2022 8:40 pm
by tapper
Hi I got rid of my wrt3200acm and swopped it for a r7800 because of the flaky wifi. I don't know how well Gargoyle runs on the r7800 tho mate.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Wed Feb 02, 2022 12:35 am
by smoke_15
Any recommendations on the top 5 routers for gargoyle? Ive had good experiences with the archer c7 and the buffalo wzr. Both are around 10 years old though, would be great to know what to replace them with if they ever died. Something as solid as those, just with faster clocks would be great.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Wed Feb 02, 2022 2:10 pm
by ispyisail
@Lantis what router are you using?

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Wed Feb 02, 2022 5:02 pm
by Lantis
Currently a Netgear R7800. It’s not as fast as the linksys WRT routers, but the wifi is much nicer. That being said, it crashes every now and then and I’m sure that is wifi related (haven’t caught it in the act yet).

Mediatek are the way to go long term.
I have a Belkin RT3200 waiting for full support.

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 7:23 am
by pythonic
Lantis wrote:
Wed Feb 02, 2022 5:02 pm
Currently a Netgear R7800. ... That being said, it crashes every now and then and I’m sure that is wifi related (haven’t caught it in the act yet).
Is this with your development builds or 1.13.x? If the former there appear to be some issues with the frequency scaling in the 5.x kernels which might be alleviated by raising the minimum clock frequency to 600MHz or 800MHz (a quicker check is just to enable the performance governor though).

Might also be related to the ct vs non-ct WiFi firmware/drivers too.
Lantis wrote:
Wed Feb 02, 2022 5:02 pm
I have a Belkin RT3200 waiting for full support.
Were you able to get that locally or is it an import?

I picked up a TP-Link A6 v3 fairly inexpensively with an eye to future support, though that's not in the same league as your Belkin...

Re: Should I turn on default QoS?

Posted: Thu Feb 03, 2022 7:32 am
by Lantis
Import :)

The R7800 is on both 1.15 and 1.13 having crashes. I saw the chatter around the frequency scaler. I've enabled ramoops and i'm waiting to catch it in the act (it is being stubbornly stable)